Rosenblum had 1,432 votes and Neuringer had 1,137, with 13 out of 15 districts reporting at 12:10 a.m.
Rosenblum, a Republican, has been mayor since 2009, and previously served as a trustee.
Neuringer, Democrat, is an architect from Mamaroneck
The race for trustee went to Louis Santoro, who led with 52-precent of the vote.
Santoro, a Republican, is a previous member of the Mamaroneck Fire Department.
Stein is a 21-year village resident and managing director at Lloyds Bank. He has coached lacrosse for a decade with the Larchmont-Mamaroneck Youth League and currently is coaching the Mamaroneck Blackhawks U-14 Travel soccer team.
Click here to follow Daily Voice Mamaroneck and receive free news updates.